Skip to content 
If you’re looking for the absolute best way to upgrade your home’s comfort and save money on heating and cooling, a smart thermostat is the answer. These clever devices learn your preferences, automate your temperature settings, and can even be controlled from your phone. What is the best smart thermostat?
I’ve been a smart home enthusiast for years, and I’ve personally tested the Nest Learning Thermostat for over a year now – let’s dive into why it might be the perfect choice for you.
My Honest Review of the Google Nest Learning Thermostat: A Smart Home Enthusiast’s Perspective
Okay, fellow tech lovers, let’s get real about the Google Nest Learning Thermostat. I’ve lived and breathed smart home upgrades for years, and I’ve had the Nest running the show in my house for over a year now. So, is it worth the hype? Let’s break it down.
What Makes the Nest Shine
- The Energy-Saving Champ: Okay, I admit I always rolled my eyes at the “save big on energy!” claims. But with the Nest, those savings aren’t just marketing hype. It learned my comings and goings like clockwork, knows when I’m home or away, and adjusts accordingly. Checking my energy history in the app gives me that warm, fuzzy feeling – I’m seeing actual proof of a lighter energy bill.
- Seriously Easy Setup: You know that fear when you unbox a new gadget, and it looks like a NASA control panel? The Nest is the opposite. They must have known that most of us aren’t HVAC experts, so the instructions are super clear, and the app guides you step-by-step. Even someone as tech-challenged as me had it up and running in no time.
- It Practically Thinks for Itself: Here’s where the Nest blows my mind. After a few days of me fiddling with the settings, it basically said, “Alright, I get your vibe!” Now I wake up to the perfect temperature, get home to a cozy house, and the best part? I haven’t had to touch the thing in weeks. It just knows.
- Remote Control for the Win: I’m the classic “left the house and can’t remember if I turned the stove off” type. With the Nest, at least I don’t stress about the AC blasting all day! Quickly adjusting the temp from my phone has saved me countless times (and probably a few extra gray hairs).
- Smart Home BFF: The Nest’s integration with my Alexa setup is the stuff of sci-fi movies made real. A simple “Alexa, make it warmer” and boom, instant cozy vibes. Sometimes it feels like the Nest is the brains of my whole smart home operation.
Let’s Be Realistic – The Drawbacks
- Pricey Upgrade: No sugarcoating it, the Nest is definitely an investment compared to those old-school thermostats. But here’s the thing: it starts paying for itself over time. The key with the Nest is thinking long-term. The energy savings (which really do add up!), less wear and tear on your HVAC system, and that can’t-put-a-price-on convenience factor make it worth it for me.
- The C-Wire Thing: Okay, this is where some smart home dreams can stumble. If you live in an older house, chances are you might not have a C-wire, which the Nest usually needs. Don’t panic! First off, check your wiring – there are easy guides online. If you’re stuck, there are often workarounds. You might be able to install an adapter or, if you’re not DIY-inclined, have an electrician take a quick look.
- Don’t Forget Your Wi-Fi: The Nest is an internet-powered little genius, so if your Wi-Fi is spotty, it will get cranky. Before buying, make sure you have strong signal coverage where your thermostat is located. If you frequently have connection issues, it might be worth investing in a mesh system or Wi-Fi booster before taking the Nest plunge.
The Smart Home Enthusiast’s Verdict
The Nest Learning Thermostat is a total powerhouse. If you’re ready to level-up your home’s comfort, save some cash on energy, and embrace that futuristic smart home feel, I give it two thumbs up. Just factor in the upfront cost and your existing home setup.
Top Alternatives to the Nest
Okay, the Nest is amazing, but it’s smart to consider all your options! Here are a few top-notch smart thermostats that also deserve a place in the spotlight:
Ecobee Smart Thermostat Enhanced with Voice Control:
My all-star pick for those who hate some rooms being too hot or too cold. Their room sensors are a game-changer! Instead of the thermostat going by just the hallway temperature, Ecobee lets you manage each room individually. Goodbye to freezing in my office while the living room feels like a sauna! And of course, Alexa integration is a must for me.
Why the Ecobee Smart Thermostat Enhanced Rocks
Okay, if you’re like me and hate battling cold bedrooms and stuffy living rooms, Ecobee’s got your back. They’re all about solving that uneven temperature problem! Here’s why it’s an awesome Nest alternative:
- Serious Energy Savings: They claim up to 26% savings on heating and cooling, AND it’s ENERGY STAR certified. That’s not just hype – between room sensors and smart scheduling, those savings can add up.
- Comfort King: This thing eliminates those “oops, forgot to adjust the temp” moments. Preheats/cools before you get home, adjusts for humidity levels – it’s about always having that perfect temp.
- Easy Peasy Installation: Like the Nest, they aim for DIY-friendly setup with clear instructions. Most folks get it up and running in less than an hour.
- Smarts that Work with (Almost) Everyone: Alexa, Siri, Google Assistant, you name it – Ecobee likely makes friends with your existing smart home setup.
- Built to Last: Ecobee isn’t messing around. This thermostat is meant to be on your wall for a good long while, which is great when you’re making that investment.
Bonus Feature: Toss in a SmartSensor, and you can monitor specific rooms like the nursery. It’s like total home temperature domination!
Things to Consider
- Cost: Ecobee can run a bit pricier than the Nest, so consider if the room sensors are worth the extra investment to you.
- HVAC Compatibility Double-check that it’ll play nice with your system, especially if you don’t have a C-wire (but they include a workaround kit!).
The Honeywell Home RTH9600WF: Smart Scheduling on a Budget
Want a dependable smart thermostat with tons of scheduling flexibility, but don’t want to break the bank? The Honeywell Home RTH9600WF might be the perfect fit. Let’s dive into the features and if it’s right for you!
Key Features
- Customizable Color Display: Match your thermostat to your home’s vibe or change colors based on the season – definitely a fun touch!
- Smart Scheduling: Honeywell focuses on flexible scheduling. You can set it for 7-day programming or adapt schedules based on your typical routines.
- Geofencing: Like the Nest, it can adjust the temperature for you when you leave or arrive, saving you from heating or cooling an empty home.
- Focus on Simplicity: While packed with features, Honeywell aims for a user-friendly experience – good for those who don’t want to get bogged down in a complex app.
- Alexa Ready: Seamless integration with Alexa for voice control enthusiasts.
Why Choose the Honeywell Home RTH9600WF?
- You Prioritize Scheduling: If you like granular control over your weekly temperature schedule, Honeywell gives you plenty of customization options.
- You Value a Budget-Friendly Option: Honeywell smart thermostats often come in at a lower price point than Nest or Ecobee competitors.
- Design Matters: The color display adds a stylish touch, and it can help the thermostat blend in (or stand out!) depending on your preferences.
Important Considerations
- C-Wire Requirement: This thermostat absolutely needs a C-wire, so make sure your system’s compatible before buying.
- No Line Volt Heating: It won’t work with electric baseboard heaters or other line volt systems.
- Fewer Bells & Whistles: Doesn’t have room sensors like the Ecobee or the Nest’s advanced learning algorithm.
Mysa Smart Thermostat for Electric Baseboard Heaters:
Tired of those outdated in-floor heating thermostats that make smart features feel impossible? Mysa is here to change that. Let’s take a look at why this is a serious upgrade.
Key Features
- Electric In-Floor Heating Specialist: Mysa understands that regular thermostats don’t cut it for in-floor heating systems. It’s designed with those systems’ unique needs in mind.
- Class A GFCI Protection: Built-in safety! Especially important with in-floor heating, which makes Mysa stand out among competitors.
- Energy Savings Focus: Smart scheduling, geofencing, and the ability to understand in-floor heating cycles all help you optimize your energy use.
- Easy Installation: Even if you’re not an electrician, Mysa strives for a user-friendly setup process with clear instructions and in-app support.
- Wide Smart Home Compatibility: Works with HomeKit, Alexa, Google Home – control it however fits best with the rest of your smart home setup.
Why Choose the Mysa Smart Thermostat for In-Floor Heating?
- If Electric In-Floor Heating is Your Thing: This is the best choice for those systems! No more clunky old thermostats or sacrificing the convenience of smart scheduling.
- You Prioritize Safety: The built-in Class A GFCI protection provides extra peace of mind.
- You Want an Energy-Saver: Mysa’s features are all about maximizing the efficiency of your in-floor heating system, potentially saving you some serious cash on bills.
Considerations
- Not for Hydronic Systems: If you have water-based (hydronic) in-floor heating, you’ll need a different smart thermostat.
- App-Reliant: Most of the control relies on the app, so it’s best for those comfortable with smartphone-centric features.
Why Consider an Alternative?
- Specific Features: Maybe you need those room sensors, or baseboard heating is your jam.
- Budget: Top-tier smart thermostats come with a premium. Alternatives might fit your wallet better.
- Smart Home Ecosystem: If you’re not tied to Google/Alexa, other brands might play nicer with your existing setup.
Remember: Do your research! Compare features, prices, and delve into reviews of these alternatives just like I did with the Nest. The perfect smart thermostat is out there for everyone!
What is the Best Smart Thermostat for You? Let’s Break it Down!
Okay, smart thermostats are awesome… but with all the options, how do you actually pick the right one for your home? Let’s break down some common scenarios to help you make that decision:
Scenario 1: “If you value seamless setup and automation…”
You’re tech-savvy, but you also value your free time. You want something that’s practically plug-and-play, and will basically take care of itself.
- Top Pick: The Google Nest Learning Thermostat. Its installation process is known for being easy, and the learning algorithm is incredibly powerful. After a while, it basically figures out your schedule and sets the temperature for you. You can even link it to other smart devices for some cool automations.
Also Consider: The Ecobee Smart Thermostat with Voice Control. Similar focus on user-friendliness, plus it includes a room sensor for even more tailored comfort.
Scenario 2: “If budget is your biggest concern…”
You want the benefits of a smart thermostat without breaking the bank. You’re willing to forgo some bells and whistles in favor of core smart features at a great price.
- Top Pick: The Honeywell Home T9 Smart Thermostat. It focuses on reliable scheduling, remote control, and energy monitoring. You get all that smart home goodness at a more budget-friendly price point than some of the premium options.
Also Consider: Wyze Smart Thermostat offers surprising features for the price, but be prepared for a slightly more involved setup process.
Scenario 3: “If you have multiple zones to control…”
Your house is a constant battle of “it’s too hot upstairs!” and “I’m freezing in the basement!” You need to fine-tune the temperature room by room.
- Top Pick: The Ecobee Smart Thermostat with Voice Control takes the win. Its room sensors let you manage individual rooms. No more sacrificing your office comfort for the sake of the living room!
Also Consider Depending on your setup, some smart thermostats can be paired with smart vents for even more granular zoned control.
Important Notes:
- HVAC Compatibility: Always, always, always double-check that your chosen thermostat works with your heating and cooling system!
- Smart Home Setup: Are you team Alexa, Google Assistant, or keeping things simple? Make sure your thermostat of choice plays nice with your existing devices.
FAQs: All Your Smart Thermostat Questions Answered
Q: Are smart thermostats really worth it?
- A: For most people, yes! The potential energy savings, increased convenience, and overall comfort upgrade make them a worthwhile investment. Factors to consider are your home’s size, how old your current thermostat is, and how much you value the “smart” features.
Q: How much money can a smart thermostat save me?
- A: This varies greatly. Smart thermostats with learning features (like the Nest) claim up to 10-15% savings on heating and cooling. Even simple scheduling helps you avoid heating/cooling an empty home. Your exact savings depend on current energy habits and your climate.
Q: Can I install a smart thermostat myself?
- A: Often, yes! Many (Nest, Ecobee, Honeywell) are designed for DIY installation. But, it’s crucial to check your HVAC system’s compatibility. Older homes might lack a C-wire. If you have any doubts, consult a professional.
Q: What’s the difference between Google Nest, Ecobee, Honeywell Home RTH9600WF and Mysa smart thermostats?
- A: There are subtle but important differences! Here’s a quick breakdown:
- Nest: Known for learning algorithm and ease of use.
- Ecobee: Prioritizes zoned comfort with room sensors.
- Honeywell: Budget-friendly, focuses on customizable scheduling.
- Mysa: The go-to choice for electric baseboard or in-floor heating.
- Always compare detailed features, price, and compatibility with your system.
Q: Do I need a C-wire for a smart thermostat?
- A: Usually. Most smart thermostats require a C-wire for consistent power. Older homes might not have one. BUT, don’t panic:
- Check your wiring first – there are easy guides online.
- Some thermostats include power adapters to work without a C-wire.
- A professional electrician can likely install a C-wire for you.
Q: Will a smart thermostat work with my old furnace/AC?
- A: It depends! Check the thermostat’s compatibility list against your HVAC system’s specs. Generally, most modern systems are fine, but it’s best to double-check.
Q: Do smart thermostats work with Alexa/Google Home/etc.?
- A: Most do! Look for clear statements about smart home compatibility on the product page. However, some smaller brands might be more limited.
Q: Are smart thermostats secure?
- A: Reputable brands take security seriously. Choose top-tier thermostats, keep software updated, and use strong passwords for related accounts.
Q: Can a smart thermostat help with high humidity?
- A: Indirectly, yes. Some smart thermostats can monitor humidity levels and may integrate with a smart dehumidifier. Some even adjust the temperature accordingly to maintain a comfortable humidity level.
Q: I have electric baseboard heating. Will any smart thermostat work?
- A: No! Most smart thermostats are designed for traditional forced-air systems. Look specifically for thermostats designed for electric baseboard or in-floor heating, such as Mysa.
Q: I rent my apartment. Can I still install a smart thermostat?
- A: It depends on your lease and landlord. Some may be open to it, but make sure you discuss it first. Remember to save your old thermostat so you can reinstall it before you move out.
Q: I have a multi-zone HVAC system. What’s my best smart thermostat option?
- A: You have a few options:
- Ecobee with multiple room sensors is a great start.
- Some systems are compatible with smart vents that work in tandem with a smart thermostat, allowing for even finer control.
- Consult with an HVAC professional to explore all your options.
Q: Does a smart thermostat work with solar panels?
- A: Not directly, but they can complement each other! Your smart thermostat’s energy-saving features can reduce your overall energy draw, maximizing the benefits of your solar panels.
Q: I’m not very tech-savvy. Are there any simple smart thermostats?
- A: Absolutely! Brands like Honeywell often focus on user-friendliness. Look for clear displays, intuitive apps, and models that prioritize core features like scheduling over multiple complicated integrations.
Q: My Wi-Fi is spotty. Will a smart thermostat still work?
- A: It depends. Most rely on Wi-Fi for remote control and updates. If you have frequent outages, you might experience disruptions. Some basic functions will work offline, but you’ll lose some of the “smartness.” Consider investing in a mesh network or Wi-Fi booster if connectivity is a concern.
Q: I care about the environment. Do smart thermostats actually help?
- A: Yes! Their biggest eco-impact comes from energy savings. Features like scheduling, learning algorithms, and geofencing all aim to reduce unnecessary heating/cooling. Look for those with ENERGY STAR certification.
Q: I travel frequently. Can a smart thermostat help with that?
- A: Definitely! Geofencing features automatically adjust the temperature when you’re away. No more worrying if you turned the AC off, and pre-heating/cooling before you arrive is a huge comfort bonus!
Q: I value privacy. Do smart thermostats collect a lot of data?
- A: Reputable brands have privacy policies outlining data collection. Make sure to read these carefully. You often have some control over what data is shared, but these devices, like all smart home tech, do collect some information to function effectively.
Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Smart Thermostat Match
While the Google Nest Learning Thermostat is my top all-around pick for its ease of use and intelligent automation, the truth is, the “best” smart thermostat is the one that best suits your needs. Here’s what to keep in mind:
- Budget-Conscious? The Honeywell Home offers solid smart features without the premium price tag.
- Prioritizing Comfort? Ecobee‘s room sensors are amazing for battling those hot and cold spots in your home.
- Unique Heating System? Mysa is the way to go for electric in-floor or baseboard heating.
No matter what you choose, upgrading to a smart thermostat is a smart move! They offer a blend of convenience, potential energy savings, and that futuristic-feeling smart home experience we all secretly crave.
Ready to explore more ways to level up your smart home? Check out my Amazon Echo 4th Gen review to see how this little wonder transforms your daily life. Or, if you’re focused on wellness, discover life-changing gadgets for health.
